We still haven't seen evidence corroborating all of what she claims. You have provided some evidence that may help her win the case. It depends on how the jury interprets. Her credibility isn't beyond reproach. It's not misogyny for me to say that. She has already been dishonest about a few things (like saying she donated the divorce proceeding to the ACLU). So far, we have seen more evidence that she initiated and perpetrated violence on Johnny. There is audio where she actually dares him to accuse her publically, because he won't be believed: he's a man. There is enough here in this situation that one can be critical of Amber without victim-blaming. Personally, I believe it was mutual abuse (just like their therapist testified). I do find it presumptive that that you feel that we must sympathize with Amber over Johnny for us to be decent people.