To be fair, he didn't have a case until his reputation was affected by her accusation. For a defamation, the statement has to cause injury. According to Johnny's lawyers, Amber preemptively tipped TMZ that she was going to file a restraining order so that she could use the publicity to garner public sympathy. She showed up to the courthouse with a bruise on the right side of her face. Camille shows photos with her and her friend, Raquel Rose Pennington, with no make up and no bruise the next day. Maybe Johnny was an abuser, but Amber's story does not add up.